Gander didn’t have a plan for thousands of unexpected guests. Its residents found beds, made meals, and opened their doors anyway. At the Erie Playhouse, Come From Away finds its heart in the kindness of people who got to work before they knew what would happen next.

After the attacks of September 11, 2001, 38 planes were diverted to Gander, Newfoundland. Come From Away follows the locals and passengers through the days that followed, moving between their stories with humor, music, and the uncertainty of people who have no idea when they’ll get home.

Director and choreographer Richard Davis keeps the story moving through a constant shift of chairs, characters, points of view, and, yes, more chairs. The actors switch between locals and passengers so often that every change needs to register immediately. Dialect coach John-Patrick Driscoll’s work helps sharpen those distinctions, especially as performers move between the voices of Gander and those of its unexpected guests.

Matt Fuchs is fantastic as Claude, the mayor suddenly responsible for keeping Gander functioning as its population nearly doubles. Fuchs is very funny, especially as Claude’s list of problems keeps growing. But the humor comes from his exasperation rather than incompetence.

Brendan Daugherty gives Oz a looser, more playful energy. His comic timing is sharp, and he brings an offbeat charm to the local constable without turning the character into a caricature.

Leah Johnson’s Bonnie is all determination. Her mission to reach the animals trapped aboard the planes could easily feel like a side story, but Johnson gives it real urgency. Her no-nonsense delivery keeps Bonnie funny, while her concern for the animals never feels anything less than sincere.

Tywan Jackson gives Bob one of the production’s strongest character arcs, as his suspicion of his unfamiliar surroundings, and an awful lot of white folks, slowly gives way to trust. Jackson gives Bob’s growing trust a believable hesitancy.

Jasse Camacho Vera is another standout as Kevin J. His always-sharp comedic timing puts an edge on Kevin’s frustration, while his scenes with Josiah Prittie’s Kevin T. reveal the strain that being stranded puts on their relationship. Prittie plays Kevin T. as someone eager to help, even as the two men respond to Gander in very different ways.

Camacho Vera also plays Ali, an Egyptian passenger who encounters suspicion at the very moment everyone else is celebrating the town’s hospitality. He lets that shift register without overplaying it, making the moment feel painfully honest.

Emily Bahm’s Janice, the young local reporter, is wonderfully human. She has a job to do and very little preparation for the size of the story in front of her. Bahm finds both the comedy in Janice’s inexperience and the resolve she develops as the days go on. She’s new.

Krista Perry’s Hannah waits for news of her son, a New York firefighter. Maribeth McCarthy’s Beulah stays beside her, and their friendship becomes one of the show’s most impactful subplots. I only cried once during the show…thanks, Krista and Maribeth.

Kate Thiem is a commanding Beverley, the pilot who has spent her life earning her place in the cockpit. “Me and the Sky” captures the joy she finds in flying before September 11 changes what a plane means to the world. Thiem plays that shift with restraint, letting the emotion arrive naturally.

Patrick Thiem brings warmth to Nick and his unexpected romance with Diane. At the performance I saw, Jessica Flock stepped into Diane, a role credited to Diane Hardner, after a mere 72 hours to learn it. That would be a difficult assignment in any show, let alone one that never stops moving like this. Flock was engaged, confident, and fully connected to her scene partners. She deserves a standing ovation of her own, honestly.

Emily Cassano, Shani Bills, Austin Blair, Michael Graham, and Paul Bills round out the ensemble, shifting quickly between Gander locals and stranded passengers with unmistakable energy.

Music director Devon Yates and the live band, made up of Jim Griffey, Greg Hardner, Jim Kipp, Moe Ferrara, Natalie Prischak, and Eric Larson drive the story forward with ease through a score that is far more difficult than it sounds.

The kindness at the heart of Come From Away feels especially relevant here at home. Erie’s arts community is full of talented and deeply caring people, but it is also a place where kindness can sometimes get lost in ego, pressure, and talk of “the good old days.” Come From Away offers a simple reminder that community is not just about who shares a stage or rehearsal room. It is about how we treat one another when plans shift, when someone new walks in, or when another person simply needs a little grace.

Come From Away has extended its run at the Erie Playhouse and will now continue through October 4. Tickets are available at erieplayhouse.org or by calling 814-454-2852.

Leave a Reply

Trending